Spiritual Doubt: Three Nondual Perspectives on Doubt ThoughtsBy Tchiki Davis, M.A., Ph.D.
*This page may include affiliate links; that means we earn from qualifying purchases of products. In some contexts, this is useful advice. But if taken to be truth, it can create serious distortion or dissociation. A person can become so committed to transcending doubt that they stop listening to the intelligence contained within their own experience.
Nonduality complicates the issue even further. If there is no separate self and no independent reality corresponding to our conceptual descriptions, then what exactly is doubt? What does it mean to doubt something? And what happens when we begin to see that both doubt and certainty are movements within a dual conceptual structure? Three Perspectives on Doubt There are at least three ways of understanding spiritual doubt. The first sees doubt as something the mind does. From this perspective, we can witness doubt thoughts without automatically believing them. The second sees doubt as something that can arise through the body and embodied intelligence. Here, doubt or resistance may contain valuable information about what is happening in our lives, relationships, practices, or spiritual communities. The third perspective recognizes that doubt depends upon conceptual distinctions. Something must first be defined as true, real, solid, meaningful, or permanent before it can be either doubted or accepted. Get The FREE Awakening eBook✓ Discover what awakening is like
✓ Learn about the four stages between awakening & enlightenment ✓ Get exercises to progress Sign up below to get our FREE eBook. Doubt as Something the Mind DoesAt an early stage of nondual awakening, it can be enormously helpful to recognize doubt as a mental activity. A thought appears saying, “Maybe this isn't working,” “Maybe awakening isn't real,” “Maybe I am doing this wrong,” or “Maybe I should stop.” Rather than immediately following the thought into loops of reasoning, we can notice that it is simply a thought.
This is one of the great discoveries on the journey. A thought can appear without requiring identification—without it being true. The mind can generate certainty, uncertainty, fear, hope, skepticism, and conviction, often changing its position from one moment to the next. Seeing this directly creates space around thought. You no longer need to take thoughts so seriously. From this perspective, the instruction, “don't believe your doubt” can be useful. It means that the appearance of a thought does not automatically mean the thought is true. The mind can produce a compelling argument for almost anything, and another thought can just as easily produce an argument against it. There can be a lightness that arises with this recognition. Doubt as Avoidance This perspective can be useful in nondual awakening because the mind often uses doubt as a sophisticated form of avoidance. A person may encounter a teaching that challenges their identity or belief system, and suddenly a huge number of objections arise in the mind. The objections may sound intelligent and philosophical, but underneath them, there may simply be resistance to losing something familiar. The same thing can happen in meditation. A person sits quietly and encounters discomfort, boredom, fear, or restlessness. The mind then produces an explanation: “This isn't the right practice for me.” Sometimes that conclusion is accurate. Sometimes it is simply the mind looking for an exit from an uncomfortable experience. The Role of Witnessing Awareness Witnessing can reveal the texture of different kinds of thoughts. Instead of immediately deciding whether the doubt is correct, we can observe the doubt itself. What is it doing? Does it create contraction? Does it produce endless analysis? Does it repeatedly move the goalposts? Does it protect an identity or belief from being challenged? In this sense, seeing doubt as thought can be liberating. The thought does not have to become a command that we do something. And yet, there is a danger here. When “It's Just a Thought” Becomes Spiritual BypassingThe recognition that thoughts are not necessarily true can easily become another spiritual belief. A practitioner may begin categorizing uncomfortable thoughts as “just the mind” and desirable thoughts as expressions of deeper wisdom. This creates a subtler form of illusion and suffering.
Further, the instruction to dismiss doubt can become dangerous when applied indiscriminately to relationships with spiritual teachers or spiritual communities. Spiritual Doubt & Cult Dynamics Suppose a student notices that a teacher's behavior feels manipulative. Perhaps the teacher discourages questions, demands unusual loyalty, creates financial dependency, violates boundaries, or presents personal opinions as absolute spiritual truth. The student thinks, “Something doesn't feel right here.” The unfortunate thing about this insight (and all insights) is that they are not good or bad; they can be perceived and understood in an infinite number of ways. So a nondual teachers' response, “That's just a doubt thought. Don't identify with it” can become new conditioning that may prevent some people from listening to the thoughts that are screaming, "Get the hell out of there!" This may be especially true for younger seekers whose sense of self has not been developing for as long. Thoughts may indeed be bubbles that arise and pop with little residue. They may mean nothing, from one level of seeing. But they may also be pointing to something important, at another level. Thoughts can still be information about what is happening in your body and in your world. Thoughts can be both meaningless and meaningful, simultaneously. This is where embodied discernment becomes important. Doubt as Something the Body DoesA second way doubt can be understood is as a bodily sensation. Rather than treating it primarily as a cognitive error, we can allow ourselves to experience it fully as an embodied phenomenon.
Perhaps the body contracts when a certain teaching is presented. Perhaps there is uneasiness around a teacher. Perhaps there is a sense of openness in one direction and resistance in another. Instead of immediately silencing the thoughts that arise from these sensations, we can listen. The thoughts, although often clumsy, are doing their best to point us to something that is happening in our lived experience. The body carries conditioning, trauma, fear, habit, and learned associations. A contraction does not automatically mean that something is wrong. A pleasant sensation does not automatically mean that something is right. And yet, the body often contains useful information that thought is trying to translate for us, even if it uses words, stories, beliefs, and memories that have little to do with what the body is trying to say. Holding Concepts, like 'Doubt', Lightly So, sometimes doubt is resistance to transformation. Sometimes it is the body recognizing something that genuinely doesn't resonate. Sometimes it is fear. Sometimes it is intuition. Sometimes it is old conditioning. Sometimes it is several of these at once. By allowing the doubt to arise in an embodied way, you give it the opportunity to reveal what it really is. Instead of asking, “Is this doubt true or false?” (which is a question that forces duality) we can ask, “What happens when I allow this doubt to be fully here?” Perhaps it is thought and it pops like a bubble. Or perhaps the body relaxes. Perhaps a deeper fear becomes visible. Perhaps an old belief is released. Or perhaps the uneasiness becomes clearer and reveals a genuine boundary that needs to be honored. Nothing Is Right or Wrong This is why telling people never to trust their 'doubt thoughts' is not quite it. Our experience of doubt evolves as we deepen. Doubt, while at times harmful, holds a treasure deep within it. All "negative" experiences hold their opposite within. And doubt, when allowed and heard, can protect us from confusion, manipulation, and spiritual authoritarianism. It is neither good nor bad. The Polarity Between Witnessing and Embodiment
From the either/or perspective, these two perspectives seem like they are opposites. Witnessing and embodiment can appear to contradict each other.
Both can be helpful and harmful. If witnessing becomes a strategy for rejecting experience, it becomes dissociation disguised as spirituality. If embodiment becomes an instruction to believe every sensation or emotional impulse, we can feel like we're drowning in experiences. From the both/and perspective, neither one is experienced as absolute. A doubt thought can be witnessed without being suppressed. It can also be felt without being believed. Its content can be explored completely without granting it authority. Doubt Requires Something to DoubtFrom the interpenetrating perspective, the whole framework through which doubt and certainty arise is seen through. Something still needs to appear to be true for doubt (or certainty) to operate.
When a teacher says, "that's just a doubt thought", they are implicit telling you what is true, what is undoubtable, and that your thoughts are untrue. Nothing anyone says is true or untrue. Every claim is arising from concepts, beliefs, thoughts, and perspectives. If I say that "You need to X, or ultimate reality is like Y", it's not just that the words are imperfect pointers, it's that the 'thing' we're pointing at only appears the way we see it through our unique perspective. Is there a contraction that falls away when you awaken? Is there a self that can be transcended? Is there an ultimate and a relative? Is one teaching more effective than another? The answer is both 'yes' and 'no', until even both/and implodes, and then there no longer appears to be a meaningful difference between answering 'yes' or 'no' to these questions. All answers simply point to the same thing through different perspectives. Doubt Thoughts Are Always Right & Always Wrong Doubt thoughts are actually always correct (in a way) because nothing is what it appears to be. Your body knows this. And if the mind is spinning with doubt thoughts, they may just be picking up on a deeper recognition that nothing is certain, that nothing can be known for sure. Doubt & Certainty as Categories To even be able to classify one of your experiences or thoughts as 'doubt' requires a mind that still holds subtle thought structures and a solid concept of 'doubt'. Ask yourself, how do you define doubt? Does someone else define it differently? How do you sort thoughts into categories with the labels of 'doubting thoughts' or 'not doubting thoughts'? Is there any way to actually determine what 'doubt' is or what 'certainty' is? Doubt does not actually exist independently of mental/conceptual interpretation. In other words, your experience is valid whether it is labeled 'doubt' or 'not doubt'. Doubt as Concept If I doubt that enlightenment is real (or if I am certain that it is real), I must have a concept of what enlightenment is. My mind holds a definition of enlightenment as something is that is actually true outside of conceptual construction. If I doubt that my partner loves me, my mind holds a definition of what love is. If I doubt that I'll make the right decision about something, my mind hold an idea of what 'right' and 'decision' are. Doubt and belief therefore belong to the same conceptual structure. So when a teacher says, “That's just doubt", they may genuinely believe they are simply helping the student move beyond unnecessary thoughts. But implicitly, the instruction often means, “Stop questioning and believe the perspective that I am presenting.” Although we call it nondual awakening when someone switches from one perspective (self/relative/suffering) to the opposite perspective (no-self, ultimate/freedom), this is really more like a stepping stone to the revelation that both sides were never separate. Doubt in the Fetter Model of Awakening
In the Buddhist fetter model, vicikicchā, often translated as doubt, is one of the fetters that is abandoned at stream entry. The fact that we experience doubts after stream entry is a clue that doubt is not just one thing; in fact, doubt could be an infinite number of things.
The doubt being addressed at stream entry is more about having a big enough glimpse that a part of you is not easily pulled away from it. Seeing through this doubt is not equivalent to losing the capacity for ordinary discernment and critical thinking. Keep those; they come in handy ;) A person can recognize the possibility of liberation directly while still questioning a particular teacher, teaching, practice, interpretation, approach, belief system, or community. All of our paths are different, and finding the right path for us often involves this kind of doubt or questioning. Discernment as WisdomAs nondual awakening progresses, discernment can become less personal. Initially, doubt may revolve around “Am I right?” or “Am I safe?” or “Am I making the correct spiritual choice?”
As nondual awakening deepens, discernment can become more embodied, more grounded. We choose spiritual teachers who withstand questioning, teachers who hold our perspectives to be just as valid as theirs, teachers who encourage students to think critically, share their doubts openly, and take their own path, even if it means not following the same path as the teacher. From an interpenetrative perspective, doubt is nothing and everything, simultaneously. Don't automatically believe your doubt, but don't automatically dismiss it either. Beyond Both Doubt and Certainty The mind wants to decide whether doubt is good or bad, trustworthy or untrustworthy, spiritual or unspiritual. But nondual revelation keeps revealing the instability of these categories. Doubt appears. Certainty appears. Resistance appears. Trust appears. Thoughts interpret them. Sensations accompany them. Concepts define them. Categories organize them. None of these are an ultimate position. No knowledge gives us access to some special reality. What could possibly elevate or separate one experience from another? Integrated nonduality does not erase ordinary intelligence. We can act in ways that honor the needs of the self while still recognizing that our conceptual interpretations are not true in the way they appeared to be. Final Thoughts on Spiritual DoubtSpiritual doubt changes as nondual understanding deepens. At one level, doubt can be recognized as a resistance of mind. At another level, doubt can be embodied and listened to fully. As these perspectives interpenetrate, both doubt and certainty are seen as arising from the same conceptual misunderstanding. To doubt something, there must be some concept of what is being doubted. To believe something, there must be some concept being accepted. Nonduality points beyond the assumption that either conceptual position is an ultimate truth.
|
Get The FREE eBook
✓ Discover what awakening is like ✓ Learn about the four stages between awakening & enlightenment ✓ Get exercises to progress Sign up to get our FREE eBook. |